In-Store Pickup
Shop Our Sweets
-
Samuel’s Candy Club Subscription
Candy, Chocolate, Free Shipping Products, Samplers, SubscriptionMake every month sweeter by joining our BRAND NEW Samuel's Candy Club! For just $44.95 per month, you or a friend can enjoy our latest & greatest seasonal shop offerings from home! Cancel anytime! You can choose any of our samplers as your first shipment, just select your preference below!$44.95 / month$44.95 / month -
Thanksgiving Desserts
Baked Goods, Pickup, SamplersBaked to pie-fection & ready for you to enjoy with loved ones! Available for in-store or curbside pickup on Tuesday, November 24 and Wednesday, November 25. Order by Sunday, November 22. 9" Pies Pumpkin Pie $25.95 Pecan Pie $29.95 Apple Pie $26.95 Apple Crumb $26.95 Blueberry Pie $27.95 Blueberry Crumb $27.95 Coconut Custard Pie $29.95 Carrot Cake $37.95 Cheese Cake $27.95 Cheese Cake with Strawberry Drizzle $30.95 Please note: You will need to enter an address to complete purchase, but these desserts are only available for in-store or curbside pickup.Price range: $25.95 through $37.95Price range: $25.95 through $37.95 -
Gobble Gobble Gift Box
Chocolate, Free Shipping Products, Samplers$49.95Hey Pilgrim! Let's talk turkey - we all have lots to be thankful for. Share our cornucopia of favorite Thanksgiving sweets with your loved ones at the dinner table this year. They're sure to Plymouth Rock your world!'Gobble Gobble Gift Box' includes:Signature Bark - dark chocolate with cherries, almonds & sea saltNine-piece truffle sampler, including our famous pumpkin pie truffleSolid Milk Chocolate Turkey$49.95 -
Deluxe Holiday Sampler
Candy, Chocolate, Free Shipping Products, Samplers$99.95'Tis the season to be sweetened! This festive selection of year-round & holiday favorites will delight everyone on your nice list! Featuring our famous homemade peppermint bark, best-selling sea salt caramels & several BRAND NEW items - including peanut brittle! 'Deluxe Holiday Sampler' includes:Peppermint barkSea Salt CaramelsPeanut BrittlePeppermint Hot Chocolate PopcornWhite Chocolate Peppermint PretzelsChocolate-Covered Gummi BearsChocolate Toffee Almonds$99.95 -
Season’s Eatings Sampler
Candy, Chocolate, Chocolate Bags, Free Shipping Products, SamplersYule flip over this fa-la-la-fantastic selection of all-time holiday best-sellers, featuring our famous homemade peppermint bark! Yum! Enjoy being home for the holidays with our most wonderful box of the year!$49.95Famous Peppermint BarkMilk Chocolate-Covered Dried CherriesDark Chocolate-Covered Dried PearsDark Chocolate Sea-Salt Caramels$49.95 -
Eight Nights of Delight Sampler
Candy, Chocolate, Chocolate Bags, Free Shipping Products, Samplers$75.00Celebrate the festival of lights with this BRAND NEW sampler packed with Hanukkah best-sellers & everyday favorites! Perfect for enjoying with family & friends during the holidays - it even comes with a dreidel! Happy Hanukkah! 'Eight Nights of Delight Sampler' includes:Nine piece truffle samplerPartners Columbian CoffeeGraham Slams! - Toffee, almonds & white chocolateHanukkah dark chocolate nonpareilsHanukkah chocolate almondsMilk chocolate geltBlue raspberry marshmallow puffsVinyl Samuel's sticker...plus a dreidel... & more!$75.00 -
Paul’s Favorites Sampler
Candy, Chocolate, Free Shipping Products, SamplersPaul's Favorites Sampler includes: Paul Rudd Marshmallow Crispy Cake* Signature Bark - dark chocolate with cherries, almonds & sea salt Clodhoppers - peanut butter, pretzel & graham cracker in milk chocolate Candy Blocks Paul Rudd's go-to sweet picks all in a gift-ready sampler! Salty, sweet and crunchy clodhoppers, a colorful assortment of candy blocks (build something, then eat it!) plus a generous assortment of our signature dark chocolate bark and, of course, a marshmallow crispy cake featuring a pic of Paul. Plus a sweet surprise!$49.95$49.95 -
Jeffrey’s Favorites Sampler
Candy, Chocolate, Free Shipping Products, SamplersJeffrey's Favorites Sampler includes: Jeffrey Dean Morgan Marshmallow Crispy Cake Signature Bark - dark chocolate with cherries, almonds & sea salt Milk Chocolate-Covered Swedish Fish Strawberry Gummi Teeth Jeffrey Dean Morgan's go-to sweet picks all in a gift-ready sampler! A bag of ghoulishly sweet strawberry gummi teeth, wickedly delicious chocolate-covered Swedish fish, plus a generous assortment of our signature dark chocolate bark and, of course, a marshmallow crispy cake featuring a pic of Jeffrey. Plus a sweet surprise!$49.95$49.95
Our Latest News
Samuel's Sweet ShopOur Spooktacular Turns 12 and It Was Fang-tastic!
Read moreOur Spooktacular Turns 12 and It Was Fang-tastic! A dozen years of Halloween fun, and this might have been our…
0
Samuel's Sweet ShopWE WON! Samuel’s Is the Hudson Valley’s Best Candy Store
Read moreSweet Victory! Samuel’s Named Best Candy Store of the Hudson Valley 2026! WE WON! 🍬🏆 Samuel’s Sweet Shop has been…
Samuel's Sweet ShopWe’re a Top 10 Candy Store in the Nation! Samuel’s Named in USA TODAY 10Best 2026
Read moreWe’re a Top 10 Candy Store in the Nation! Pinch us, we must be dreaming! 🍬 Samuel’s Sweet Shop has…
Samuel's Sweet ShopA Boo-tiful Afternoon at Samuel’s 11th Annual Halloween Spooktacular 2025!
Read moreA Boo-tiful Afternoon at Samuel’s 11th Annual Halloween Spooktacular 2025! Eleven years in, and our Halloween Spooktacular is still the…
