fbpx
(845) 876-5312 | Shop Location

Home

Shop Our Sweets

  • $44.95 / month

    Samuel’s Candy Club Subscription

    , , , ,
    Make every month sweeter by joining our BRAND NEW Samuel's Candy Club! For just $44.95 per month, you or a friend can enjoy our latest & greatest seasonal shop offerings from home! Cancel anytime! You can choose any of our samplers as your first shipment, just select your preference below!
    $44.95 / month
    $44.95 / month
  • $49.95

    Pot O’Candy Sampler

    , , ,
    Search no further - Samuel’s is at the end of the rainbow! Celebrate the luckiest time of the year with this shamrockin’ collection of sweets! Pot O’Candy Sampler includes:
    Lucky Charms Bark
    Rainbow Fruit Slices
    Dark Chocolate Mint Truffles
    Matcha Green Tea Almonds
    Milk Chocolate Gold Coins
    $49.95
    $49.95
  • $49.95

    Paul’s Favorites Sampler

    , , ,
    Paul's Favorites Sampler includes: Paul Rudd Marshmallow Crispy Cake* Signature Bark - dark chocolate with cherries, almonds & sea salt Clodhoppers - peanut butter, pretzel & graham cracker in milk chocolate Candy Blocks Paul Rudd's go-to sweet picks all in a gift-ready sampler!  Salty, sweet and crunchy clodhoppers, a colorful assortment of candy blocks (build something, then eat it!) plus a generous assortment of our signature dark chocolate bark and, of course, a marshmallow crispy cake featuring a pic of Paul. Plus a sweet surprise!
    $49.95
    $49.95
  • $49.95

    Jeffrey’s Favorites Sampler

    , , ,
    Jeffrey's Favorites Sampler includes: Jeffrey Dean Morgan Marshmallow Crispy Cake Signature Bark - dark chocolate with cherries, almonds & sea salt Milk Chocolate-Covered Swedish Fish Strawberry Gummi Teeth Jeffrey Dean Morgan's go-to sweet picks all in a gift-ready sampler!  A bag of ghoulishly sweet strawberry gummi teeth, wickedly delicious chocolate-covered Swedish fish, plus a generous assortment of our signature dark chocolate bark and, of course, a marshmallow crispy cake featuring a pic of Jeffrey. Plus a sweet surprise!
    $49.95
    $49.95
  • $49.95

    Hilarie’s Favorites Sampler

    , , ,
    Hilarie's Favorites Sampler includes: Hilarie Burton Marshmallow Crispy Cake Signature Bark - dark chocolate with cherries, almonds & sea salt Coconut Curry Cashews Milk Chocolate Sea Salt Caramel Popcorn Hilarie Burton's go-to sweet picks all in one gift-ready sampler!  Delicious chewiness of popcorn mixes with the silkiness of milk chocolate with a kick of salt and caramel. These sweet 'n salty milk chocolate-covered popcorn morsels truly are 'clouds of awesome,' as Hilaire calls 'em! Savory meets sweet in the decadent bites of cashew delight.  Add in a generous assortment of our signature dark chocolate bark and, of course, a marshmallow crispy cake featuring a pic of Hilarie. Plus a sweet surprise!
    $49.95
    $49.95
  • $99.95

    Deluxe Dinner Party Sampler

    , , ,
    This scrumdiddlyumptious selection of dinner party favorites will leave guests wishing they saved ALL the room for dessert! Featuring our BRAND NEW Samuel's Bar & our famous peanut butter cup blondie recently featured in PEOPLE Magazine! Yum! 'Deluxe Dinner Party Sampler' includes: Soft 'n chewy favorites from our chocolate case Caramel peanut butter cups Savor 'Plainville' shortbread cookies Honey roasted Virginia peanuts Samuel's Bar (winning ticket inside?!)* PEOPLE Magazine peanut butter cup blondie Classic malted milk balls Scrumptious triple chocolate toffee *Winning Ticket inside?! You could win a three month subscription to our Samuel's Candy Club!
    $99.95
    $99.95
  • $49.95

    Nuts About You Sampler

    , , ,
    The reviews are in, & nut’ins better than our ‘Nuts About You Sampler!’ Spread the love with our award-winning, perfectly selected mix of sweet & salty favorites! Nuts About You Sampler includes: Our award-winning Over the Tops – peanut butter cups sandwiched between two unlocked double stuf OREOs...dipped in milk chocolate Coffee Toffee Peanut Bark – milk chocolate blended with espresso, toffee & our famous salted Virginia peanuts Almond Buttercrunch – rich toffee dipped in milk chocolate & rolled in almonds. A classic Samuel’s hit since we opened in 1994
    $49.95
    $49.95
  • $49.95

    Cookies ‘n Dreams Sampler

    , , ,
    Om nom nom nom! Cookie lovers rejoice...this sampler is wayyy too tasty to share! Just add milk - everything is simply doughlicious! Cookies 'n Dreams Sampler includes: AWARD-WINNING Next Level Sensations - peppermint patties sandwiched between two unlocked double stuff OREOs...dipped in minty dark chocolate Cookies 'n Cream Bark Milk chocolate-covered cookie dough Milk chocolate-covered mini OREOs Plus a few sweet surprises!
    $49.95
    $49.95

Our Latest News

  • Poughkeepsie Journal Profiles Samuel’s Sweet Shop Ahead Of Anniversary

    John W. Barry of The Poughkeepsie Journal stopped by Samuel’s Sweet Shop ahead of our 25th anniversary.  He visited with manager and co-owner John Traver as well as co-owners Paul, Julie and Andy.

    Read more
  • Samuel’s Wins BEST DESSERT third year in a row at Taste of Rhinebeck!

    WE WON 🎉  John & Team proudly displaying People’c Choice & Chef’s Choice awards for BEST DESSERT, as well as the Ira Gutner Hospitality Award.

    Read more
  • Jeffrey Dean Morgan Talks Samuel’s With Jimmy Fallon

    Samuel’s co-owner Jeffrey Dean Morgan stopped by The Tonight Show with Jimmy Fallon and brought Jimmy a basket of treats! 

    Read more
  • Paul Rudd Shares Samuel’s Sweets with Seth Meyers

    No Comments

    Samuel’s Sweet Shop co-owner Paul Rudd stopped by Late Night with Seth Meyers with some sweets from Samuel’s in tow.  Check out the clip below to watch Paul and Seth enjoy some delicious Andy “The Other Guy” Ostroy Rice Crispie treats.

    Read more
Load More

Meet The Sweet Team

Jeffrey

Hilarie

Paul & Julie

Andy

John

Subscribe for the latest from Samuel's!

You'll get a 15% off coupon code for your first order when you join our mailing list.

We respect your privacy and will never share your data.